A Difficult Journey
It is difficult to visit an extermination camp. It is difficult to do so because it is difficult to come to terms with an extermination.
We must be clear: the only tool we have at our disposal to understand an extermination, a genocide, is the study of history: where it took place, when it took place, why it took place, how it took place, who carried it out, and who the victims were. As regards the last two questions, it must be said that they are not listed in order of priority: both these groups of people must be understood. And, in my view, our investigation of them must be guided not by emotions – such as anger or pity – but by the need to know, and thus to understand, and thus to be aware. For me, the study of history serves to understand what came before us, and thus also, to some extent, to understand who we are, but not to develop the capacity for indignation or solidarity; for these latter natural stirrings of the soul, a sense of ethics (if one possesses it) is sufficient.
A mass extermination, a genocide (and here I am referring to real ones, not those that exist only in religious or political imagination) must therefore be understood first and foremost through study. This involves studying books, in which authors weave documents into a narrative, and the direct study of documents themselves, provided one has first learnt to interpret them and understand what they truly contain. Testimonies, whether written or oral, are obviously documents to be studied as well. Even the spatial dimensions of a barrack, or the track gauge – that is, the distance between the rails of a railway track.
Why do people visit an extermination camp? They go because there are traces there. […] The visit will have a positive effect if it is undertaken with humility, setting aside emotional reactions (which are present, and very strong) in favour of reflection on what one sees and on the silence one hears (or ought to hear).
The search for traces
So why do people visit an extermination camp? One goes there because there are traces there. Traces of the camp and traces of the extermination. Extermination kills people, annihilates them once and for all, one by one and all at once. This is what happened in the former Nazi camps of Treblinka, Sobibór and Bełżec, for which eyewitness accounts are extremely rare (a visitor might prepare for this journey of discovery by studying how few there are and why they are so rare). But the events of the extermination themselves also leave traces: the size of the camp, its (probable) proximity or (unlikely) distance from the road or railway line (with the related question of what travellers saw and/or imagined), the size of the mass graves sometimes used (and for what purpose), the tiny fragments of burnt bones that one may still happen to tread upon whilst walking over what remains of the Treblinka camp, the nearest parish church and inn – and therefore, probably, those most frequently used by those who lived there. These are traces. Traces of lives cut short; traces of the lives of those who cut them short.
Experience, emotion, knowledge
Yes, seeing them up close has an impact. But for it to have the ‘impact of knowledge’, one must arrive at the camp having already studied its chronology, operation and ‘accounts’. The study trip can enhance and reinforce prior knowledge, but it cannot replace it.
And the visit will have a beneficial effect if it is undertaken with humility, setting aside emotional reactions (which are present, and very strong) in favour of reflection on what one sees and on the silence one hears (or ought to hear).
Alongside all this, it is worth always bearing in mind that, alongside those who are there to seek knowledge, or to seek a deeper understanding, there are other people who travel to Treblinka, Sobibór and Bełżec simply as human beings visiting a cemetery: to visit the non-graves of the relatives of their grandparents, great-grandparents and great-great-grandparents. At times, for these visitors, those ‘non-cemeteries’ hold a number of relatives that is without equal. Even the study, for those who go there with this aim, may be without equal.