Franz Schubert’s song cycle Winterreise, composed in 1827, is the emblematic work of European Romanticism. It describes the solitary journey of a Wanderer, a traveler in despair over a disappointment in love, through a cold and inhospitable nature in which he nonetheless finds a mirror of himself and, in the end, a kind of consolation. From the very first lines, the wanderer defines himself as fremd, a stranger – an existential condition perhaps inherent to this figure, one from which there can be no way out: Fremd bin ich eingezogen, fremd zieh’ ich wieder aus, “A stranger I arrived, a stranger I depart.”
Lager-Reise seeks to tell an equally desperate journey, triggered by a radical failure and devoid of any prospect of consolation: a journey through the sites of Nazi extermination in Poland, today.
The route does not follow the chronology of the camps’ construction, but draws its inspiration from the railway lines that once connected the great cities (Warsaw, Kraków, Lublin, and others) to the extermination centers – trajectories the project team has physically retraced on its journeys to Treblinka, Sobibór, Bełżec, Majdanek, Auschwitz, Chełmno: the Vernichtungslager, the extermination camps or, etymologically, the camps of annihilation.
Beginning at the end of 1941, these places saw the systematic elimination of the Jews carried out: the final phase of the Endlösung der Judenfrage, the “final solution to the Jewish question” – first with the elimination of the Jews of the Warthegau, then of the General Government of Poland, and finally with the deportations from Germany and the occupied countries.
As part of the PRIN PNRR 2022 project Conceptualising and Representing the ‘Other’ in the Polish, Ukrainian, Jewish and Yiddish Cultural Fields, directed by Laura Quercioli of the University of Genoa, we carried out three journeys between 2024 and 2025. The first, through east-central Poland, from Warsaw to Treblinka, Sobibór, Bełżec and Majdanek, with the support of the Polish Institute in Rome and the coordination of Anna Jagiełło. The second to Chełmno, with the support of the research project coordinated by Katrin Stoll of the University of Jena (funded by the DFG – Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft). Finally, a third journey took us from Kraków to Auschwitz-Birkenau.
Going today to the places where, more than eighty years ago, the annihilation of Europe’s Jews was carried out – seeing and perceiving the state of the places – allows us to observe how culture attempts to respond to the failure and radical collapse of culture itself, brought about by the carrying-out of the Shoah, and how art and architecture try to confront the anthropic Nothing (das Nichts) produced by non-Jews at the expense of Jews.
The gaze we have adopted is that of the traveler who, in observing, can neither wish nor manage to appropriate the tragedy, but accepts the weight of their own share of involvement, of responsibility.
The aim is to document, through a subjective gaze guided by discipline and respect, the current state of these places and, at least in part, their memorial initiatives, while also offering essential historical references and reflections: notes, further reading, texts gathered in preparing for the journey or that accompanied us through the pages of our notebook.
Finally, we would like to show and convey the transformations and the suffering of nature in the places of the camps. «How can you remain so beautiful, blue skies, while they are massacring us?» wrote the poet Yitzhak Katzenelson. The answer lies in the celebrated definition offered by Martin Pollack, who captured the heavy affliction that still weighs on these contaminated landscapes.
Beyond Auschwitz
On Auschwitz as a symbol of the Shoah – epitome of Evil, anus mundi, the only true capital of Europe, symbol of European conscience – enough volumes have been written to fill more than one library. The centrality of Auschwitz-Birkenau in (perhaps) shared historical memory has been built both on an overestimation of the number of victims (once thought to be 3 or 4 million, though the latest research has confirmed that 1,100,000 Jews and 160,000 non-Jews were murdered there), and on the fact that people were deported there from every country of occupied Europe.
Moreover, Auschwitz brings together, within a single area and administration, the concentration camp (Auschwitz I) and the labor camp (Monowitz), where death was extremely likely – through exhaustion, hunger, disease, executions, torture – and the extermination camp (Birkenau), where death was inevitable and almost immediate. Birkenau was the final realization of the project of annihilation through fixed structures for gassing victims and cremating bodies: the first Vernichtungslager – camp of annihilation – was Chełmno, followed by Bełżec, Sobibór, and Treblinka. Majdanek too, the concentration camp near Lublin, had a gas chamber and a crematorium.
A few thousand prisoners of the Auschwitz concentration camp survived – unlike what happened in the Vernichtungslager – and were able to bear witness. From this arose the project, conceived as early as 1946 – that is, before the founding of the Polish national Museum, opened in 1947 – to create a series of national pavilions, designed and managed by individual governments in agreement with the museum institutions, in memory of all those groups who were deported and murdered at Auschwitz. A decision probably indispensable (and appealing to the visitor and tourist), but one that largely contradicts the very we that it might have symbolized: we human beings, we Europeans, we Jews – where Jew could stand not for some often-resented other, but for the very epitome of European and Western history.
But Auschwitz was not the first former camp to be turned into a museum-memorial: even before the war ended, in November 1944, the former German concentration camp KL Lublin-Majdanek became the Majdanek State Museum.
If today Auschwitz finds itself confronting a phenomenon such as mass tourism, if not outright overtourism, the other former camps remain places difficult to visit, drawing far fewer numbers, yet visited out of a strong sensitivity to historical and memorial concerns.
Why Lager-Reise
The forests that should have welcomed the wanderer became scenes of death, mute witnesses and silent accomplices of destruction, and nature, seemingly unchanged, remains contaminated by violence to this day.
The choice of a German title, Lager-Reise, is deliberate. Not only because it recalls the language of the apparatus that conceived and carried out the machinery of extermination, but also because it forces the observer to confront the deep tension between two seemingly irreconcilable terms.
Lager evokes the entire infrastructure of death, the industrial logic of annihilation. The term itself – “camp” – belongs to that euphemistic lexical strategy that Nazism adopted to veil the reality of extermination behind neutral or deceptive words. To speak of Lager, then, also means confronting a contaminated language, one that demands a continual questioning of what is being named and how it is named.
Reise – “journey” – derives from a Germanic root meaning “to rise, to set oneself in motion.” In German culture, the term evokes the figure of the Wanderer, the solitary, pensive traveler who immerses himself in nature in search of consolation, reflection, spiritual elevation. The very concept of Wandern, walking in nature, is a foundation of the German Romantic and identitarian sensibility, a profoundly cultural gesture.
Lager-Reise overturns all of this: the forests that should have welcomed the wanderer became scenes of death, mute witnesses and silent accomplices of destruction, and nature, seemingly unchanged, remains contaminated by violence to this day. Moreover, while for the victims the journey to these places was not a choice but a forced deportation, for today’s visitors it should be a path of observation and reflection, a critical setting-oneself-in-motion.
As in the Winterreise cycle, here too the traveler is alone, in an inhospitable landscape – not because of its apparent nature, which is beautiful, but because of its deep, underlying nature, one that continues to bring to the surface traces of the violence that took place there more than eighty years ago. There is no possibility of identification or catharsis: only the radical need to see, to cross, to try to understand the mechanisms of violence through the traces that remain.
Team
Laura Quercioli Mincer
Professor of Polish Literature and Culture at the University of Genoa. Her research focuses on Jewish-Polish culture and forms of transmitting memory in literature and the visual arts. Her most recent publications include the edited volume Visual Art, Place and Memory. Testimony and Rooting (2022), and ‘I Call Heaven and Earth as Witnesses’. Art, Nation and Memory in Poland and Germany – 2002–2020 (2023, Genoa University Press). Since 2010 she has been editor of “La Rassegna Mensile di Israel”; from 2022 to 2024 she served as president of the Italian Association of Polish Studies (AIP). In 2026, her monograph Towards an Ethics of Melancholy: Mirosław Balka, History, the Shoah is due to be published by Castelvecchi. She is the principal investigator of the project of national significance (PRIN) Conceptualising and Representing the “Other” in the Polish, Ukrainian, Jewish and Yiddish Cultural Fields (2024–2025).
Elżbieta Janicka
University lecturer, photographer, and essayist. She graduated from the Université Paris VII Denis Diderot (1994) and the National Film, Television and Theatre School in Łódź (1998), and earned her doctorate (2004) and habilitation (2021) at the University of Warsaw. Her scholarly and artistic practice is devoted to questions of antisemitism and the Shoah. As a photographer, Janicka draws on a distinctive strand of conceptualism, exemplified by the Warsztat Formy Filmowej (Workshop of the Film Form), founded at the Łódź Film School in the 1970s. A well-known example of her photographic work is the series Miejsce nieparzyste (Odd Place; 2003–2004): six large-format black-and-white photographs and thirteen audio recordings that give visual and sonic form to the air above the extermination camps.
Elena Pirazzoli
Independent researcher working on visual culture, memory studies, difficult heritage, and public history. She holds a PhD in Art History from the University of Bologna, and in 2024–2025 is a collaborator on the PRIN project Conceptualising and Representing the “Other” in the Polish, Ukrainian, Jewish and Yiddish Cultural Fields. From 2019 to 2023 she was a Wissenschaftliche Mitarbeiterin at the Universität zu Köln, working on the project “The Massacres in Occupied Italy, 1943–45, in the Memory of Their Perpetrators.” She collaborates with the Fondazione Villa Emma in Nonantola (MO), the Scuola di Pace di Monte Sole (BO), the Risiera di San Sabba in Trieste, the national network of Historical Institutes of the Resistance, the Fondazione Home Movies – Archivio Nazionale del Film di Famiglia, and the theatre company Archivio Zeta.
Anna Jagiełło
Art historian, graduate of the University of Warsaw, curator of the art and theatre program at the Polish Institute in Rome. She has curated and organized several exhibitions of Polish art, most recently, with Jakub Gawkowski, Workers of Art. Industry and Art in the Polish People’s Republic (Rome, 2025). Her work is devoted to introducing Italian audiences to Polish art and theatre, and to fostering dialogue between Polish and Italian artists, experts, and scholars. Among her other projects, she has curated Polish Avant-Garde. Art and Culture in Poland, 1914–1952 (2020, Quodlibet) and, with Jerzy Malinowski, Polish-Italian Artistic Contacts, 1944–1980 (2023, Polski Instytut Studiów nad Sztuką Świata).